This article is produced and financed by NIVA - Norwegian Institute for Water Research - read more

Domestic wastewater is proven to play the most significant role in causing the nitrogen/phosphorus changes in Chinese lakes. Imbalance of nutrient status may facilitate the growth of toxic cyanobacteria.
Domestic wastewater is proven to play the most significant role in causing the nitrogen/phosphorus changes in Chinese lakes. Imbalance of nutrient status may facilitate the growth of toxic cyanobacteria.

Wastewater treatment changes nutrient balance in lakes - can lead to growth of poisonous algae

A vast number of new wastewater treatment plants in developing countries has led to an imbalance between phosphorous and nitrogen in surface waters. The result could be excessive growth of potentially poisonous algae with a preference for nitrogen.

Published

As one of UN’s 17 sustainable development goals, clean water and sanitation receives a lot of attention. In order to reach this comprehensive goal, efficient municipal wastewater management plays a major role. Most human activities produce wastewater – and the annual production of municipal wastewater worldwide now exceeds the amount of water released by the enormous Amazon river to the Atlantic Ocean in roughly 12 days.

“The volume of wastewater is continuing to grow with urbanization and the associated population increase. Increasing wastewater production, together with inadequate collection and treatment facilities, have led to negative impacts on water quality”, NIVA researcher Yan Lin said.

According to Lin, many developing countries are addressing the issue by fast construction of new wastewater treatment plants.

“The difference in nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiency, however, has resulted in imbalance of nitrogen relative to phosphorus in water bodies. This may have negative implications for biodiversity and overall functioning of the receiving aquatic ecosystem,” Lin said.

Both nitrogen and phosphorus are essential elements for organisms to grow. However, as excessive nutrients may cause eutrophication of waterbodies, it is very important to control the nutrient fluxes into these waters.

Wastewater treatment boom in China

Many countries are tackling the problem of excess nutrients by increasing municipal wastewater treatment capacity. This is often more achievable than reducing nonpoint nutrient sources, for instance through reducing fertilizer application rates and watershed conservation practice.

In China, the construction of wastewater treatment plants has grown rapidly in the last fifteen years.

In 2005, the percentage of municipal wastewater being treated on a national scale in China was only about 40 per cent. In 2017, it reached more than 90 per cent.

However, the results of this shift of measures in relation to nutrient concentrations in lakes are unknown.

As wastewater treatment plants are better at reducing phosphorus compared to nitrogen, the imbalance between these two elements is changing on a worldwide level, particularly in developing countries.
As wastewater treatment plants are better at reducing phosphorus compared to nitrogen, the imbalance between these two elements is changing on a worldwide level, particularly in developing countries.

May lead to algae blooms

In a fresh PNAS publication a broad consortium of scientists, including experts from the Norwegian Institute of Water Research (NIVA) show that this municipal wastewater treatment boom in China is a major driver for increases in nitrogen/phosphorous mass ratios in the country’s lakes. This is especially significant in the more populated Eastern China.

The main reason is that phosphorus is more effectively removed than nitrogen from wastewater in most of the current wastewater treatment plants, the researchers argue.

“We investigated the changes of the nutritional status of 46 major lakes in China. While the water in general is becoming cleaner, the findings show that the phosphorus is decreasing at a much faster pace,” NIVA researcher Lin said.

The results show that in the past decade, phosphorus concentration in most lakes in eastern China has dropped significantly. Nitrogen concentration, on the other hand, has been mostly stable. Thus, the ratio of nitrogen to phosphorus has kept on increasing.

According to Lin, this can bring some unexpected consequences for the functioning of aquatic food webs, such as the increasing prevalence of certain types of cyanobacteria in the eutrophic lakes.

“Our findings highlight the need for more efficient nitrogen reduction in addition to phosphorus reduction in wastewater treatment to reduce the risk for phytoplankton blooms and toxin production and to maintain ecosystem biodiversity in downstream waterbodies,” Lin said.

Good balance essential

Not familiar with the term nutrient stoichiometry? No worries, you’re not alone. The term can be described as a science that explores the balance of important life elements such as carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus in various ecological processes. Its core is to reveal the impact of changes in the living environment and biological element composition on the overall function of terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems.

Just like humans thrive best on a diet with a good balance between carbohydrates, protein and fat, nature also has certain preferences. A good balance between nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorous is essential.

To maintain healthy waters with good biodiversity, wastewater treatment plants have been installed to prevent too many nutrients being deposited in nature. However, in the fresh PNAS paper the researchers argue that it is due time for the wastewater treatment plants to develop more efficient nitrogen removal technologies.

“Mastering the long-term evolution of the stoichiometric characteristics of nitrogen and phosphorus in waterbodies is a prerequisite for clarifying changes in primary productivity of aquatic ecology and discovering potential drivers of negative ecological consequences,” Lin said.

Call for new regulations

The NIVA researcher argues that the project’s results should be taken into account when evaluating the implementation of environmental management measures and formulating future nutrient management and control goals.

“The growing imbalance between nitrogen and phosphorous has important implications for aquatic ecology that remain poorly considered and understood,” Lin said.

“The current regulations need to be updated to include the nutrient stoichiometry parameters rather than single nutrient limit values,” he said.

In particular, the results of the study should have great implications for wastewater treatment policy making in developing countries, where massive infrastructure developments, including wastewater treatment plants, are undergoing.

“The design of wastewater treatment plants should more efficiently reduce nitrogen in addition to phosphorus, in order to keep the nitrogen/phosphorus mass ratio at balance,” Lin concludes.

Facts:

  • Increases in total nitrogen/total phosphorus mass ratios were observed in many of China’s freshwater lakes during 2008 and 2017. This is caused by the difference in the rates of change in nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations in lakes, as phosphorus showed significant decrease while nitrogen remained relatively stable.
  • Among the major sources from human activities, domestic wastewater is proven to play the most significant role in causing the nitrogen/phosphorus changes in lakes. The removal efficiency of phosphorus in wastewater treatment plants is usually much higher than that of nitrogen. Thus, for populated areas with the percentage of wastewater being treated by wastewater treatment plant increased rapidly, the nitrogen/phosphorus in the wastewater treatment plant effluent increased by nearly two times compared with ten years ago.
  • This imbalance in the ratio between nitrogen and phosphorous may, among other things, facilitate the growth of toxic non-N2 fixing cyanobacteria.

About the research:

The research was conducted in collaboration with Tianjin University, Tsinghua University, Peking University, Norwegian Institute of Water Environment (NIVA), Spanish Institute of Global Ecology, University of North Carolina, University of Montana, Wageningen University and a number of other research institutions. Dr. Yan Lin from NIVA and Dr. Xin Dong from Tsinghua University are the corresponding authors of the study.

Reference:

Yindong Tong et al, (2020) “Improvement in municipal wastewater treatment alters lake nitrogen to phosphorus ratios in populated regions”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences May 2020, 117 (21) 11566-11572; DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1920759117

———